American Journal of Sports Science
Volume 4, Issue 1-1, February 2016, Pages: 27-30

Comparative Analysis of Health Related Fitness Among Female Vegetarian Athletes of Football, Basketball and Volleyball

Anindita Das, Ravi Sharma

Lakshmibai National Institute of Physical Education, Gwalior, Madhya Pradesh, India

Email address:

(A. Das)

To cite this article:

Anindita Das, Ravi Sharma. Comparative Analysis of Health Related Fitness Among Female Vegetarian Athletes of Football, Basketball and Volleyball. American Journal of Sports Science. Special Issue: Kinanthropometry. Vol. 4, No. 1-1, 2016, pp. 27-30. doi: 10.11648/j.ajss.s.2016040101.15


Abstract: The study was conducted to compare the health related physical fitness of vegetarian athletes of different team games like Football, Basketball and Volleyball. Sixty female athletes (21.2 ± 2.4 year) were studied out of which twenty were from Football, twenty were from Basketball players and rest were from Volleyball. Significant differences were observed only in endurance whereas no significant differences were observed in flexibility, body composition, muscle strength and muscular endurance.

Keywords: Health Related Fitness, Vegetarian, Football, Volleyball, Basketball


1. Introduction

Athletes require an adequate food intake to meet the high level of energy expenditure, to maintain the homeostasis, to prevent exercise – related stress disorders, to achieve an appropriate body composition, and to sustain athletic performance [1]. When activity is to be done, fuel is required. This fuel must be supplied by food which is burnt chiefly in the active muscles [2]. Female athletes are expected to be fit, lean and competitive in their sport. They also have the pressures of today’s society, which places a high emphasis on body image and thinness. A person who does not eat or does not believe in eating meat, fish, fowl, or, in some cases, any food derived from animals, as eggs or cheese, but subsists on vegetables, fruits, nuts, grain etc are known as vegetarians. Many first class athletes have been vegetarian provided the protein intakes is adequate, vegetarian diets are suitable for hard training. There is no evidence that extra protein is beneficial: nor does it do any harm [3]. Physical fitness is typically defined with focus on two goals: performance and health. Health related physical fitness can be defined as the ability of a person to perform daily activities with vigor, and by traits and capacities that are associated with a low risk for the development of chronic diseases and prevention of premature death. Health related components are very essential for the athlete’s performance. The components of fitness each work together to contribute to the ability of the body to handle physical demands. The more efficient the body functions, the higher the level of fitness. Optimal fitness is a combination of lifestyle, nutrition, habits, but it cannot be reached without an appropriate level of physical activity. Optimum physical performance is a combination of all the components of fitness; depending on the specific demands of the sport or activity. Some components will require more attention than others, but each should be present as a part of an integrated training program [4]. Health-related fitness relates to those components of fitness that are affected by habitual physical activity and relate to health status. As mentioned above, they include aerobic functioning, body composition, and musculoskeletal functioning [5]. Thus the study was conducted to reveal the significant role of diet in health related physical fitness and components of different team games.

2. Method

2.1. Subjects

A total of 60 female vegetarian athletes were selected from football, basketball and volleyball by using purposive sampling. The age of the subjects were ranged from 18 to 24 years. Players were with regular game practice with good level of skill and playing for the last 4 years in regular basis. Out of sixty players, 20 were from Football, 20 from Basketball and 20 from Volleyball. All the players had similar life styles including physical activities, diet, daily routine exercise program, sleeping time as they were all in sports hostel under controlled supervision. All the tests were administered on each player individually with the help of standard scientific instruments.

2.2. Ethical Issue

Consent was taken from each subject and the study was approved by the ethical committee of the Institute.

2.3. Criterion Measures

Health related fitness variable Criterion measure
Endurance 12 min run/walk test
Flexibility Sit and Reach test
Lean Body Mass (LBM) Skinfold method
Muscular strength Push ups
Muscular endurance Sit ups

2.4. Administration of Tests

2.4.1. Endurance

12 min run- walk test was conducted on 200 m track. The length of track was divided into 8 equal posts of 25 m each. All the subjects were assembled at starting line. They were instructed to run continuously for 12 min and if they felt tired they could walk instead. A score was assigned to each of the runners to keep record of the number of laps completed and the part of a lap run within stipulated period. The subject started running at the sound of the clapper by starter by a time keeper. After 12 min a long whistle was blown and all the subjects stopped running.

2.4.2. Flexibility

Flexibility was measured with the help of sit and reach box. The tester with the help of flexomeasure case was faced down. The subject sat down near the edge of the flexomeasure box behind the zero mark while knees were in locked position. As subject prepare to stretch. with the heel apart not more than 5 inches, subject slowly stretched forward while pushing flexomeasure by both hands. The reading was taken near the edge of flexomeasure case.

2.4.3. Lean Body Mass (LBM)

Lean body mass (LBM) obtained from subtracting the observed fat amount from the body weight. Durnin and Womersley [6] technique was followed for body density. Body fat% was derived from the equation of Brozek et al [7].

2.4.4. Muscle Strength

Muscle strength was estimated from Push Ups by a standard method [8].

2.4.5. Muscular Endurance

Muscular endurance was estimated from Sit-Ups by a standard method [8]. The performer performed maximum number of sit – ups in 1 minute was recorded.

2.4.6. Statistical Analysis

Data were analyzed with Statistical Package SPSS (IBM) version 20.

3. Results

Finding pertaining to the descriptive Statistics of the players from selected groups on the health related fitness variables has been presented in Table 1. The values of mean, standard deviation and standard error of mean for Football, Basketball and Volleyball were shown in Table 1.

Table 1. Descriptive Statistics of the players from selected groups on the health related fitness variables.

Table 2. Test of Homogeneity of Variances.

  Levene Statistic df1 df2 Significant value
Flexibility 0.315 2 57 0.731
Endurance 1.058 2 57 0.645
Lean Body Mass (kg) 0.070 2 57 0.932
Muscular Strength 0.567 2 57 0.570
Muscular Endurance 2.822 2 57 0.068

To test the equality of variances, Levene’s test was used. The F-value was insignificant as the p-value was more than.05. Thus the null hypothesis of equality of variances might be accepted, and it was concluded that the variances of the two groups were equal. The results were presented in Table 2.

None of the health related fitness variable showed significant differences except endurance which was shown in Table 3. In the case of flexibility, body composition, muscular strength and muscular endurance, the p- values were greater than 0.05. There were no significant differences among these variables in Football, Basketball and Volleyball. But in case of endurance, p-value was less than 0.05. Thus, there were significant differences in endurance of Football, Basketball and Volleyball players. Since f-value was significant in endurance, post hoc test was needed for comparing the means of groups.

Table 3. ANOVA of the present study.

Sum of Squares df Mean Square F Sig.
Flexibility Between Groups 93.1 2 46.55 2.003 0.144
Within Groups 1324.713 57 23.241
Total 1417.813 59
Endurance Between Groups 602974.8 2 301487.4 10.991 0.000
Within Groups 1563524 57 27430.25
Total 2166499 59
Lean Body Mass Between Groups 39.669 2 19.834 3.118 0.052
Within Groups 362.629 57 6.362
Total 402.297 59
Muscular Strength Between Groups 20.1 2 10.05 0.142 0.868
Within Groups 4020.5 57 70.535
Total 4040.6 59
Muscular Endurance Between Groups 126.233 2 63.117 0.873 0.423
Within Groups 4121.95 57 72.315
Total 4248.183 59

Table 4. Tukey Post Hoc Test for endurance.

Dependent Variable (I) types of sports (J) types of sports Mean Difference (I-J) Std. Error Significance value.
Endurance Football Basketball 85.50 52.37 0.24
Volleyball 242.10* 52.37 0.000
Basketball Football -85.50 52.37 0.24
Volleyball 156.60* 52.37 0.011
Volleyball Football -242.10* 52.37 0.000
Basketball 156.60* 52.37 0.011

Difference between Football and Volleyball was significant as the p-value for the mean difference was less than 0.05. Similarly, the mean difference between Basketball and Volleyball was also significant as the p-value was less than 0.05. However there was no difference between the means of Football and Basketball.

4. Discussion

The purpose of the present study was to compare the health related physical fitness among female vegetarian athletes from Football, Basketball and Volleyball. No significant difference were observed in case of flexibility, body composition, muscular strength and muscular endurance of all athletes (Table 3). But in case of endurance there was significant difference among female athletes of Football, Basketball and Volleyball.

Football is a game which requires more endurance The game Basketball also requires endurance but less than Football whereas Volleyball need less endurance than the other two games. Hence, a significant differences were observed among the three different games (Table 3). In case of other health related physical fitness variables, more or less they were required in all the three games due to which these variables had shown insignificant difference among the athletes.

Previous Studies revealed that vegetarian diet did not have neither a beneficial nor a detrimental effect on physical performance, especially when carbohydrate intake was concerned [9, 10, 11, 12]. An emphasis on plant foods was needed to enhance carbohydrate intake and optimize body glycogen stores, which might lead to increase in dietary fiber intake to reduce the bioavailability of several nutrients, including zinc, iron, and some other trace minerals. However, there was no convincing evidence, that vegetarian athletes suffered impaired nutrient status from the interactive effect of their heavy exertion and plant-food based dietary practices to the extent that performance, health, or both were impaired. Although there had been some concern about protein intake for vegetarian athletes, data indicated that all essential and nonessential amino acids could be supplied by plant food sources alone as long as a variety of food was consumed and the energy intake is adequate. There had been some concern that vegetarian female athletes were at increased risk for oligoamenorrhea, but evidence suggested that low energy intake, not dietary quality, was the major cause. In conclusion, a vegetarian diet person was not associated with improved aerobic endurance performance.

Different studies had shown that vegetarian athletes could meet their protein needs from predominantly or exclusively plant-based sources when a variety of these foods were consumed daily and energy intake was adequate. Studies revealed that muscle creatine stores were lower in vegetarians than non-vegetarians. Though creatine supplementation provided ergogenic responses in both vegetarian and non-vegetarian athletes, most of the studies supported greater ergogenic effects on lean body mass accretion and work performance for vegetarians [13, 14, 15, 16].

5. Conclusion

Only endurance of health related fitness has shown significant difference in female vegetarian Football, Basketball and volleyball players. No significant differences were observed for flexibility, Lean Body Mass, Muscular strength and Muscular endurance. It could be inferred that in the game of Football high level of endurance was required as compared to Basketball and Volleyball.


References

  1. Borrione, P.,Grasso, L.,Quaranta,F., Parisi,A., Vegetarian diet and athletes, International Journal of Sports Medicine,2009,10(1): 53-60.
  2. Howard,A.W., Nutritional and physical education, The journal of physical education and Recreation,1956,5: 29-31.
  3. Davidson,S., Meiklejhon,A.P.,Passmore,R., Human Nutrition and dietetics,New York: Longman Group Ltd.,1975,P.661.
  4. Garzón,M.J.C., The ALPHA Health Related Fitness Test Battery for Children and Adolescents, December 2009; pp: 4-12.
  5. Winnick,J.P., X. Short,F.X., Assessing Your Child's Health-Related Physical Fitness, NCHPAD, 2013, pp 2-8.
  6. Durnin,J.V.G.A.,Womersly,J., Body fat assessed from total body density and its estimation from skinfold thicknesses, British Journal of Nutrition, 32:77-79,1974.
  7. Brozek,J.,Grande,F.,Anderson,J.T.,Keys,A., Densiometric analysis of body composition: revision of some quantitative assumption, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences,110:113-140,1963.
  8. Baechile,T.R., Earle,R.W., Essentials of Strength Training and Conditioning, National Strength and Conditioning Assocation, 3rd Edition,2008 Human Kinetics,USA.
  9. Nieman,D.C., Physical fitness and vegetarian diets; is there a relation? The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1986,570-574.
  10. Barr, S.I.,Rideout, C.A., Nutritional considerations for vegetarian athletes, 2004,); 20(7-8):696-703.
  11. Timothy J. K.,Nutritional studies of vegetarians, The Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1954,2(2): 20-25.
  12. Perryet,C.L., T Mcguire,M.T.,Neumark Sztainer, D.,N.,Story,M., Characteristicsof Vegetarian Adolescents in a Multiethnic Urban Population, Journal Of Adolescence Health,2001,6:406-416.
  13. Hebbelinck, M., Clarys,P., Malsche,A.D.,Growth, Development, and Physical Fitness of Flemish Vegetarian Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults,American journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1999, 70(3):579-585.
  14. F. Sallis,J.F., Pinski, R.B.,Grossman,R.M., Patterson,T.L., R Nader,P.R., The development of self-efficacy scales for health related diet and exercise behaviors, Medicine and Health Education Research,1988,3:283-292.
  15. Raben A, Bente, K.,Erik, R.,Rasmussen,L.B.,Birgit, S.,Snezana M.,Poul,B., Serum Sex Hormones and Endurance Performance after a Lacto-Ovo Vegetarian and a Mixed Diet,Medicine Science Sports Exercise,1992,24:1290-1297.
  16. Clarys, P. D., Hebbelinck,M.,Physical Fitness and HealthRelated Parameters in Vegetarian and Omnivorous Students,Nutrition and Food Science, 2000,30(5):243-249.

Article Tools
  Abstract
  PDF(189K)
Follow on us
ADDRESS
Science Publishing Group
548 FASHION AVENUE
NEW YORK, NY 10018
U.S.A.
Tel: (001)347-688-8931